Davis, of ottawa, was the leading contractor for the masonry and the phoenix bridge company for the. Perhaps the most notorious failure in canadian engineering history was the collapse during construction of the bridge over the st lawrence near quebec city. This segment is created using footage from the summer of 2007, the. Quebec bridge is a rail, road and pedestrian bridge situated on the st. Volume 2 has a wealth of photos of the first bridge in the second. A commission of prominent international engineers was formed by the canadian government to investigate the collapse of the quebec bridge. The bridge construction was finally completed in 1917 after two. Collapse of the quebec bridge, 1907 journal of performance. Quebec bridge disaster disasters of the century youtube. Quebec city, qc bridge collapse, sept 1916 gendisasters.
Final the failure and reconstruction of the quebec. Lawrence river near quebec city, the massive quebec bridge has a history of triumph and tragedy. Bridge collapse resulted in a 6hour detour to get from one side of big sur to the other side, effectively splitting the community in half. Near the end of a long day, he noticed that a rivet that he had driven no more than an hour before had snapped clean in two. Lawrence river in quebec, canada was going to be the longest cantilever bridge in the world. Download pdf report and plans also report on design of. A cantilever bridge was proposed as the most fea sible design to bridge the harsh, icy waters of the st. Quebec bridge collapse by samuwell udayanga on prezi. The 1907 collapse of the quebec bridge crossing the st. The quebec bridge collapse a preventable failure part 1 fixing the blame anizational culture and quebec the collapse of quebec bridge 1907 failure case stus the collapse of quebec bridge 1907 failure case stus the collapse of quebec bridge 1907 failure case stus.
The quebec bridge is a road, rail and pedestrian bridge across the lower saint lawrence river. This animation only illustrates the construction of the second bridge that started in 1911, 4 years after the collapse of the first bridge. The quebec bridge is a riveted steel truss structure and is 987 m 3,239 ft long, 29. Quebec bridge disaster, never to be forgotten youtube. Pdf the quebec bridge was completed in 1917 and it is still the longest cantilever. Quebec bridge project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. The twisted remains of the 1907 quebec bridge collapse. Request pdf collapse of the quebec bridge, 1907 in the late 19th century, the transportation needs of quebec led to proposals for bridging the st. In the late 19th century, the transportation needs of quebec led to proposals for bridging the st. Serrell to make a study of the problem and make recommendations for a bridge. It took three tries and cost 89 lives, but the city of quebec was determined to compete with provincial rival montreal for commercial rail traffic in the late 19th century.
The failure and reconstruction of the quebec bridge gandhi. Quebec bridge disaster, last edited march 04, 2015. Lawrence river from its early planning stages in the 1850s, through the construction phase that ended in 1917, and on to the present day. Vautelet, a former engineer for the canadian pacific railways, maurice fitzmaurice from britain, who worked on the construction of the forth bridge, and ralph modjeski from chicago. Before the quebec bridge was built, the only way to travel from the south shore of the st. The reason for this disaster can be found in the years before in. Montreal, qb overpass collapse kills five, oct 2006. In early 1852, the city council of quebec city requested edward w. Nobody wanted to stop the project the final design wasnt checked. Oct 23, 2017 we could talk about many aspects of the quebec bridge collapse in 1907, but in this article well focus on the decisions that were made in the days leading up to the failure of the worlds longest. A summary and analysis of bridge failures by maynard horace tweed a thesis submitted to the graduate faculty in artial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of science major subject. The quebec bridge collapse august 29, 1907 1 the quebec bridge collapse august 29, 1907.
In 1882 quebec bridge company was granted the contract for the bridge due to short finance, nothing was done until 1887 when quebec bridge was incorporated with the railway company now the new management demanded to get the project rolling a. The quebec bridge is the longest cantilever span in the world, with a centredistance of 549m 1,800 ft between supports. Quebec bridge collapse ethics by anthony stackpole on prezi. The first in a three part series on the quebec bridge.
After a royal commission of inquiry into the collapse of the quebec bridge in august 1907, construction started on a second bridge. Media in category bridge collapses the following 5 files are in this category, out of 5 total. Lawrence river at quebec city shows how engineering miscalculations can lead to disaster. The five worst bridge collapses in canadian history back to video nine years later, the bridges centre span fell into the st. The bridge construction was restarted in 19 and completed in august 1919.
It was at time of construction the longest cantilever bridge in the world with clear span of 1800 ft. Volume 2 has a wealth of photos of the first bridge in the second half of the book. Quebec bridge quebec city 2020 all you need to know. On 29 august 1907, the south arm and part of the central section of the quebec bridge collapsed into the river in. Lawrence river to the south part were popular in the mid to late 1800s to allow ease of transport. The bridge construction was finally completed in 1917 after two failures or tragedies to. A new bridge was planned and erected using compression chords with almost twice the crosssectional area to. Quebec bridge, canada 1907 the quebec bridge is known for the two separate failures which occurred during construction, the first in 1907 and the second in 1916, with the tragic death of 86 workers. The lead engineer didnt listen and waited till the last minute to pause the project. The five worst bridge collapses in canadian history.
However, on august 29, 1907, during its erection, the bridge collapsed killing 75 workers. The quebec bridge was designated a national historic site in 1995. A bridge with two tragedies november 1, 2000 by james m. Theodore cooper had been the consulting engineer for the quebec bridge project, and most of the blame for the disaster fell on his shoulders. Changes of the plan before construction was to begin, cooper lengthened the span from 1600 ft to 1800 ft. Pdf movements of the quebec bridges suspended span. It is with keenest regret that we record the collapse on aug. Ideas over building a bridge that connected the north part of the st. The quebec bridge took twenty years of planning and construction before it was open to the public in 1917. If you book with tripadvisor, you can cancel up to 24 hours before your tour starts for a full refund. Nov 01, 2000 the twisted remains of the 1907 quebec bridge collapse. This failure occurred 100 years ago, and in addition to its historical interest, the report details the lessons learned that are not only timeless, but still relevant today. A cantilever bridge was proposed as the most feasible design to bridge the harsh, icy waters of the st. Construction accidents 10 reasons why bridges collapse.
In 1989, a group crossing the bridge started intentionally swinging it. Collapse of the quebec bridge, 1907 request pdf researchgate. Report and plans also report on design of quebec bridge download report and plans also report on design of quebec bridge ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. The large allowable stresses caused the buckling of a compression member, which led to further overstressing of additional members, causing complete collapse quebec bridge disaster, 1908. The quebec bridge was twenty years in the making, from the founding of the quebec bridge company in 1887 to the bridge s collapse in 1907. Collapse of the quebec bridge, 1907 cynthia pearson. The over 100yearold bridge not only connects communities and businesses on both sides of the st. See this photo for some documentation of the 1916 collapse.
Harrowing accidents such as the collapse of the quebec bridge in canada as far back as 1907 1 and the damage to transmission towers in south china due. The bridge was only partially constructed, but parts were already bending and breaking from the weight of the bridge itself. The university of houston s college of engineering presents this series about the machines that make our civilization run, and the people whose ingenuity created them. Lawrence river, on a hot august day in 1907, a worker named beauvais was driving rivets into the great southern span of the quebec bridge. Brownlee and cos locomotive opouri which crashed through the bridge at the present site of daltons bridge over the pelorus river. Also available for download is a large over 1gb zip file of high resolution jpegs of this book. During this time, there were two accidents 1907, 1916. The reason for this disaster can be found in the years before in the design and a prior failure. This editorial comments on the collapse of the south cantilever of the quebec bridge and is published as a companion article to a detailed description of the.
Presented by things simplified a new perspective 2. Second collapse of the bridge on 11 september 1916 quebec bridge again collapse in to the river killing men. A summary and analysis of bridge failures maynard horace tweed iowa state university follow this and additional works at. Iowa state university ames, iowa 1969 signatures redacted for privacy. He also modified specifications that would allow for higher. Nov 28, 2016 eng 3000 york university ali dianat, armin ghaemi, amirhossein khademi, sean obrien, kevin suarez. Lawrence river became a barrier to eastwest transportation montreals success was appealing so in 1887, the quebec bridge company was formed the hired help the phoenix bridge company of phoenixville, pennsylvania was given the contract the head engineer of the project was theodore cooper one of the most. Quebec bridge collapse civil engineering structural. Lawrence river heard a load boom like a canon shot as two compression chords of the south anchor arm of the bridge failed. The collapse of the quebec bridge, 1907 failure case studies.
Quebec bridge second bridge interactive simulations. Almost 12 years to the day after the tragic collapse, the prince of wales opened the memorial to the men lost in the quebec bridge collapse. The quebec bridge structure plunged over 150 feet taking with it the lives of 75 workers. The winkley bridge was a pedestrian suspension bridge in arkansas. First quebec bridge palm beach arch bridge attica bridge chester river bridge. We recommend booking quebec bridge tours ahead of time to secure your spot. Click download or read online button to report and plans also report on design of quebec bridge book pdf for free now. The engineer that knew the problem only sent letters to the lead engineer and waited to go to talk to him. Aug 22, 2017 the following is in honor of the 33 kahnawakehro. The collapse of the quebec bridge in 1907 remains one of the worlds major. Just as he called out to his foreman to report the disquieting. It was replaced with a 310footlong span steel bridge that opened to traffic on october 2017. Report and plans also report on design of quebec bridge.
Saint lawrence river crossing bridge, between quebec city and levis, quebec. Since the bridge has changed functions over the years, the loadings the bridge carries have currently been calculated and are compared to the loadings that the bridge was designed for. Lawrence river, but is also a national historic site and a source of pride for quebeckers. Report on design of quebec bridge volume 2 this is the official investigation report following the collapse of the first bridge. Report of the royal commission on the quebec bridge inquiry. In this handsome work, civil engineer and historian middleton traces the history of the quebec quebec bridge across the st. The day after the first collapse the canadian government implemented a royal commission, empowering it to make immediate investigations. Lawrence river became a barrier to eastwest transportation montreals success was appealing so in 1887, the quebec bridge company was formed the hired help the phoenix bridge company of phoenixville, pennsylvania was given the contract the head engineer of the. The quebec cantilever bridge, halfcompleted in august 1907 collapsed while under construction, killing 75 of the bridge workers and injuring 11 others. Quebec bridge disaster 1907 images all disaster msimages. Volume ii contains minutes of proceedings and printed exhibits for the royal commission investigating the august 29, 1907 collapse of the quebec bridge during construction. The university of houston s college of engineering presents this series about the machines that make our civilization. Fifteen seconds later the bridge collapsed into the st. The quebex bridge was a long time in planning, the original design come from the quebec bridge company in 1887, of which hon.
This series also contains photographs of the 1907 bridge collapse and pictures taken in 1965 of the current second bridge. The bridge collapsed during construction on august 29, 1907, killing eightysix workers. Harrowing accidents such as the collapse of the quebec bridge in canada as far back as 1907 1 and the damage to transmission towers in south china due to snow as recently as 2008 2,3, have. They caused the bridge to sway so fiercely that the support structures failed and the bridge collapsed, killing five source. The collapse was initiated by the buckling failure of chord a9l, on the anchor arm near the pier, immediately followed by chord a9r. Tragedy and pride mark 100th anniversary of quebec citys. Quebec bridge collapse free download as powerpoint presentation. The quebec bridge disaster transportation research board. He also modified specifications that would allow for. The project failed twice, at the cost of 88 lives, and took over 30 years to complete. The quebec bridge was the longest cantilever structure attempted until that time. Lawrence river requiring a single cantilever span 1,800 feet long the longest ever attempted. Case study of the quebec bridge collapse, the only bridge with two. Engineers were concerned, but unable to take action swiftly enough.
1163 891 942 630 222 328 580 418 1088 352 1180 1066 1055 811 144 984 1094 553 201 1186 487 1436 1038 350 373 1119 801 132 163 61 486 1006 569 762 947 1458 596 156 844 510